How to Respond to a Pre-Adverse Action Letter

When applying for a job, a background check is often part of the hiring process. If an employer finds something concerning in your report, they may send you a pre-adverse action letter—a notice that they are considering taking negative action based on the background check results.

If you receive one of these letters, don’t panic. You have legal rights and an opportunity to respond. In this guide, we’ll break down everything you need to know about handling a pre-adverse action letter effectively.

Understanding a Pre-Adverse Action Letter

A pre-adverse action letter is a formal notification from an employer stating that information in your background check may impact their decision to hire, promote, or retain you.

Why Employers Send Pre-Adverse Action Letters

Employers use pre-adverse action notices to comply with the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA). This federal law ensures that job applicants have a chance to dispute inaccuracies before a final hiring decision is made.

What’s Included in a Pre-Adverse Action Letter?

A proper pre-adverse action letter should contain:

• A copy of your background check report
• A statement of intent to potentially take adverse action
• A summary of your rights under the FCRA
• Contact details for the background check company

If any of these elements are missing, the employer may not be in full compliance with FCRA regulations.

Reviewing the Background Check Report

Once you receive a pre-adverse action notice, your first step is to carefully review the background check report provided. This is your opportunity to catch errors and correct them before they affect your job prospects.

Common Errors in Background Checks

Background checks aren’t always perfect. Mistakes happen, and some can cost you a job opportunity. Look for:

Common Error	Explanation
Incorrect criminal records	Another person’s record mistakenly associated with yours
Outdated information	Expunged or dismissed charges still appearing
Misreported employment history	Jobs or dates that don’t match your actual work history
Mismatched identity details	Wrong Social Security Number, name, or date of birth

How to Verify Your Background Check

1. Cross-check all personal details (name, DOB, SSN, addresses).
2. Compare the report with your records (court documents, pay stubs, etc.).
3. Check for duplicate or incorrect criminal offenses.
4. Look for missing context (e.g., a dismissed case reported as a conviction).

If you find errors, gather proof to challenge the inaccurate information.

Determining the Best Course of Action

Once you’ve reviewed the background check report, it’s time to decide how to respond. Depending on the accuracy of the information, your next steps will vary.

When to Dispute the Report

If you find errors or outdated information, you should dispute them immediately. Disputing incorrect records can prevent unfair adverse action against you.

You should file a dispute if:

• The report contains criminal records that don’t belong to you.
• The information is outdated (e.g., an expunged record still appears).
• Employment or education history is incorrect.
• Your credit history (if applicable) contains errors.

When to Provide Context Instead of Disputing

If the report is accurate but could be misinterpreted, it’s often helpful to provide an explanation. This applies if:

• You have a criminal record but have since rehabilitated.
• There were extenuating circumstances behind a financial or legal issue.
• A past employment gap is misleading without context.

Employers may reconsider their decision if they understand the full story.

When to Accept the Employer’s Decision

If the report is accurate and aligns with company policies for disqualification, you may have to accept the decision and focus on future opportunities.

How to Dispute Errors in a Background Check

If you find mistakes in your background check, you have the right to file a formal dispute. Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), background check companies must investigate disputes within 30 days.

Steps to Dispute a Background Check

1. Contact the background check company listed in the pre-adverse action letter.
2. Submit a dispute in writing (email or certified mail is best).
3. Provide supporting documents (court records, pay stubs, proof of identity, etc.).
4. Follow up regularly to ensure the dispute is processed.
5. Inform the employer that you’re disputing the report.

What Happens Next?

• The background check company must investigate and correct any errors within 30 days.
• If changes are made, the employer must review the corrected report before making a final decision.
• If the employer still decides against hiring you, they must send a final adverse action letter.

Writing a Response to the Pre-Adverse Action Letter

Your response should be professional, factual, and well-structured. Whether disputing errors or providing context, it’s important to be clear and concise.

Key Elements to Include in Your Response

✔ Acknowledgment – Confirm receipt of the pre-adverse action letter.
✔ Statement of Dispute or Explanation – Clarify errors or provide context.
✔ Supporting Evidence – Attach documents that support your claim.
✔ Request for Consideration – Politely ask the employer to reconsider based on your response.

Sample Response Template

Subject: Response to Pre-Adverse Action Notice

Dear [Hiring Manager’s Name],

I am writing in response to the pre-adverse action letter I received on [date] regarding my background check. After reviewing the report, I noticed [explain the error or provide necessary context].

Attached, you will find supporting documents, including [list documents], verifying that [explain your correction or explanation].

I kindly request that you reconsider your decision based on this information. Please let me know if you require any additional details.

Thank you for your time and consideration. I appreciate the opportunity to clarify this matter.

Best regards,
[Your Name]
[Your Contact Information]

---

Following Up on Your Response

After submitting your response, timing and follow-ups are key.

How Long to Wait?

Employers typically wait at least five business days before taking final action. However, if you filed a dispute with the background check company, it may take up to 30 days for an investigation.

What If the Employer Still Moves Forward with Adverse Action?

If the employer decides to reject your application, they must send a final adverse action letter that includes:

• A statement of their final decision.
• Your right to request another copy of your background check.
• Instructions on how to dispute the report further if needed.

What If the Employer Ignores FCRA Requirements?

If the employer fails to follow FCRA rules, you may have legal grounds for action. Consider:

• Filing a complaint with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB).
• Consulting a labor attorney for potential legal recourse.

Conclusion

Receiving a pre-adverse action letter can be stressful, but it’s not the end of the road. You have the right to review, dispute, and respond before an employer makes a final decision.

Key Takeaways:

✅ Review your background check carefully for errors.
✅ Dispute inaccurate information with evidence.
✅ Provide context if needed to explain valid records.
✅ Follow up with the employer and ensure FCRA compliance.

By taking swift action and advocating for yourself, you can protect your employment opportunities and ensure that hiring decisions are based on accurate information.

FAQs: How to Respond to a Pre-Adverse Action Letter

1. What is a pre-adverse action letter?

A pre-adverse action letter is a notice from an employer informing you that negative findings in your background check may affect your job offer or employment status. It gives you a chance to review and dispute any inaccuracies before a final decision is made.

2. Is a pre-adverse action letter the same as being rejected for a job?

No. Receiving a pre-adverse action letter does not mean you’ve been rejected. It means the employer is considering not hiring or promoting you based on your background check, but they must give you time to respond before making a final decision.

3. What should I do after receiving a pre-adverse action letter?

• Review your background check for errors or outdated information.
• Decide if you need to dispute inaccuracies or provide additional context.
• Submit a written response with supporting documents if needed.
• Follow up to ensure your response is considered before a final decision is made.

4. How long do I have to respond to a pre-adverse action letter?

Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA), employers must give you a reasonable amount of time—typically 5 to 7 business days—to review and dispute the report before taking adverse action.

5. What if my background check contains incorrect information?

If your background check has errors:

1. Contact the background check company listed in your pre-adverse action letter.
2. File a dispute with evidence (court records, ID verification, etc.).
3. Notify the employer that you are disputing the report.
4. The background check company has 30 days to investigate and correct errors.

6. Can an employer ignore my dispute and reject me anyway?

No, employers are legally required to consider your dispute before making a final decision. If they reject you without reviewing your dispute, they may be violating the FCRA, and you may have legal options.

7. What happens after I dispute the background check?

• The background check company must investigate within 30 days.
• If the dispute is valid, they must correct the error and notify the employer.
• The employer must review the updated report before making a final decision.

8. What should I include in my response to a pre-adverse action letter?

• A formal response letter acknowledging the notice.
• A clear explanation of errors or relevant context.
• Supporting documents (court records, pay stubs, reference letters, etc.).
• A request for reconsideration and a professional tone.

9. What if the employer proceeds with adverse action after my response?

If the employer decides not to hire or promote you, they must send a final adverse action letter explaining their decision. The letter must include:

• A copy of your background check.
• Contact details for the background check company.
• Instructions on how to dispute the report further if needed.

10. Can I take legal action if my rights were violated?

Yes. If an employer:

• Fails to provide a pre-adverse action letter before rejecting you.
• Ignores your dispute and proceeds unfairly.
• Does not follow FCRA regulations regarding your background check.

You may be able to file a complaint with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) or seek legal help from an employment attorney.